Accountability of the EDPB: challenging “shadow laws

Since November 2023*, I have been giving lots of thought to EDPB accountability – and how to challenge it. The recent General Court judgment setting aside Meta’s challenge to the Consent or Pay Opinion appears at odds with the Advocate General’s Opinion in the CJEU case regarding a WhatsApp binding decision of the EDPB. The CJEU […]

Read Analysis →

General Court’s “Consent or Pay” decision: a hollow EDPB victory?

The General Court’s dismissal of the annulment action against the Consent or Pay Opinion may seem like an EDPB victory, but consider this: (i) The General Court just said “[t]hose are therefore opinions to which no special authority is attached” (para. 28). In other words, “it’s just paper”, or “what you say in there isn’t […]

Read Analysis →

Rethinking the ePrivacy Directive: a critical legislative review

Better Regulation: Rethinking (or getting rid of?) the ePrivacy Directive” – going past the soundbites, this is a hard look at the ePrivacy rules and whether they should still exist today. Readers will know I have often criticised the European Data Protection Board’s views on Article 5(3) of the ePrivacy Directive (the “cookie” rule) because […]

Read Analysis →

“Better Regulation”: Rethinking (or getting rid of?) the ePrivacy Directive

The European Commission’s announcement that it will consider simplifying regulatory regimes, notably in relation to data and technology, seems to open Pandora’s box. Is it a chance to draw lessons from what works well and what works less well? In this series on “Better Regulation” in relation to the digital economy, I will be exploring […]

Read Analysis →

Lessons from a US lawyer who let an unverified AI chatbot invent legal citations

AI won’t replace you, you’ll be replaced by someone who uses AI” – or perhaps “you will replace someone who uses AI badly”? A U.S. lawyer appears to have ignored key�AIgovernance�rules, in a case where ChatGPT was asked to do legal research on behalf of the lawyer and ended up making up references (very realistically […]

Read Analysis →

The Spanish AEPD updates cookie guidance following the EDPB opinion

The Spanish AEPD updated its cookie guidance to take into account the EDPB’s “Consent or Pay” Opinion 08/2024 – changes on pages 29 & 30 in Spanish (see highlighting in the machine translation attached; pages 33 & 34 of the PDF). This shows exactly why the many flaws of the Opinion are problematic: they *are* […]

Read Analysis →

How the revised Spanish AEPD guidelines impact local adtech monetization

The Spanish AEPD updated its cookie guidance to take into account the EDPB’s “Consent or Pay” Opinion 08/2024 – changes on pages 29 & 30 in Spanish (see highlighting in the machine translation attached; pages 31 & 32 of the PDF). This shows exactly why the many flaws of the Opinion are problematic: they *are* […]

Read Analysis →

A deep dive into the updated cookie policies from Spain’s AEPD

The Spanish AEPD updated its cookie guidance to take into account the EDPB’s “Consent or Pay” Opinion 08/2024 – changes on pages 29 & 30 in Spanish (see highlighting in the machine translation attached – pages 31 & 32 of the PDF). This shows exactly why the many flaws of the Opinion are problematic: they […]

Read Analysis →

Navigating consent or pay modifications introduced by the Spanish AEPD

The Spanish AEPD updated its cookie guidance to take into account the EDPB’s “Consent or Pay” Opinion 08/2024 – changes on pages 29 & 30 in Spanish (see highlighting in the machine translation attached). This shows exactly why the many flaws of the Opinion are problematic: they *are* having an impact on DPAs’ practices. More […]

Read Analysis →

Why flaws in the EDPB opinion are creating a domino effect across DPAs

Thanks Luis. This shows exactly why the many flaws of the Opinion are problematic: they *are* having an impact on DPAs’ practices. More about those flaws: https://lnkd.in/enEGy9Ad We will discuss some of that (among many other topics) during tomorrow’s (free) 2h webinar on Adtech & Metrics. Register now! https://lnkd.in/eWfBq8Tn Edit: see EN machine translation with […]

Read Analysis →